What the number on the scales doesn’t tell you

The number on the scales can change by a kilo or more from one day to the next, and very little of that is fat. Water, salt, what you ate last night, how much you slept and your menstrual cycle all move it around.

So when a single number decides how you feel about yourself for the day, it’s worth knowing what it’s measuring.

Weight and body fat aren’t the same thing

Your weight is everything at once. Muscle, bone, water, organs, food in your system and body fat.

For your health, the amount of body fat matters more than weight itself, and where that fat sits matters too. Fat stored around your middle, but more specifically around the organs, is more closely linked to health risks than fat stored elsewhere.

Body fat and weight do tend to move together, which is why weight became the standard measure. It’s easy to track. That doesn’t make it the most useful one.

Why your waist is worth measuring

A tape measure tells you something the scales can’t. One helpful guide, recommended by NICE, the UK’s health guidance body, is to keep your waist measurement to less than half your height. So if you’re 164cm tall, a waist under 82cm is a good sign.

Measure halfway between the bottom of your ribs and the top of your hips, after breathing out normally. Once a month is plenty.

Small losses count

You don’t need to reach a particular number to feel the benefit. Research consistently shows that losing around 5% of your body weight and keeping it off can improve things like blood pressure and blood sugar.

For someone weighing 80kg, that’s 4kg. A steady loss you keep beats a fast one you regain.

Other ways to track progress

Your scales give you one data point. These give you a much fuller picture.

How your clothes fit. Try on the same pair of jeans once a month.

Your waist measurement, taken monthly as mentioned above.

Your energy. Notice how you feel mid-afternoon, or on the walk up the stairs.

Your cravings and your mood. Both often change weeks before the scales do.

How you feel about food. Less guilt and fewer Monday restarts are progress, even if nobody else can see them.

Writing these down once a month gives you something solid to look back on when the number won’t move.

If you do use the scales

Some women find weighing themselves useful. If that’s you, weigh at the same time of day and look at the trend over several weeks. One reading on its own tells you very little.

If the number sends your mood into a spin, it’s fine to step away from it for a while. Your progress doesn’t disappear because you stopped measuring it one way.

A better measure of success

What you’re after is a healthier body and an easier relationship with food, for good. Losing weight is part of that, and a welcome part. It isn’t the whole story.

Inside The Habit Reset we track progress in lots of ways, and the scales are rarely the most useful one. If you’re tired of letting a number decide your day, that’s a good place to start.

Next
Next

One dinner for the whole family, even with fussy eaters